Thinking of Mutual Funds? Think again.
It has been consistently demonstrated that your investment returns aren’t so much a function of what stocks your invested in, but what sectors/asset classes your invested in. In the dot com boom, it didn’t matter what dot com stock you invested in, if you were invested in dot com companies, you probably did alright. During the dot com bust, it wasn’t just a couple select companies that went down, it was just about all of them. Because of this tendency for similar stocks to move together, it is much more productive to be able to simply buy ” or short – a type of stock, then try and nail the exact right company. But how can you gain exposure to a sector without taking unnecessary risk based on the company?
The answer lies in a little tool known as the ETF. ETF stands for Exchange Traded fund. Think of it as a mutual fund that isn’t actively managed, focuses on a certain area, and can be traded like a stock without incurring extra penalties. Each ETF holds a number of companies, similar to a mutual fund, and its listed price is simply the overall value of the companies it holds.
Each ETF is designed to mimic an investment in a certain industry, region, or type of stock. Some examples of ETFs are the XLI, XLU, and EWC. These ETFs grant an investor exposure to the industrial sector of the S&P 500, the utilities sector of the S&P 500, and the entire Canadian stock market, respectively. Similarly, one who simply wanted to match the S&P 500 indexs returns could just invest in the SPY.
Yet if ETFs are so similar to mutual funds, why not just use a mutual fund. There really are a couple reasons to do so. First off, mutual funds have a history of underperforming the stock market as a whole after fees are included. This makes simple index investing, through an ETF representing a large basket of stocks, such as the SPY, an extremely effective way of matching the markets returns with nearly no cost. There are also slight tax advantages with ETFs compared to mutual funds. Mutual funds have to pay capital gains tax whenever they sell one of their holdings, and whenever they have a large wave of redemptions, they have to sell their positions to come up with the money. This leads to excess fees, some of which get passed on to the remaining investors.
Perhaps the biggest consideration is the simple convenience of owning ETFs when compared to mutual funds. They can be bought and sold (or shorted) any time during the trading day, using the same order types available to normal stocks. Free from redemption fees, the only deterrent from actively trading an ETF is belief in the efficient market hypothesis, and the standard commission costs from buying and selling stocks
Another important consideration is that most of the more liquid ETFs are optionable. This means that option-savvy investors can harness the power of stock options to change the risk-reward profile of their positions, and risk-conscious investors can use stratagems such as the covered call and protective put to protect their investment.
One thing to note is that not all ETFs are created equal. While some simply hold a basket of stocks and use those to keep the ETFs value near the benchmark, many use other, more exotic strategies, with various degrees of success. QLD for instance, aims to gain roughly twice the daily returns of the Nasdaq composite index, and is usually fairly consistent when doing this. Another similar instrument is the ETN, which is actually a debt based instrument. While ETNs also aims to gain returns based on a given benchmark, there price is also sensitive to changes in the debt rating of the issuer, and this should be considered when investing in them.
ETFs are a powerful tool for both the intelligent investor, and the active trader. Their ability to hone in and diversify within a given industry, or region of the world is invaluable when riding the larger megatrends that happen periodically in investment. Similarly, the ability to trade them just like a stock, using techniques such as shorting, options, and the various order types make them an invaluable asset for the active trader. For those believing the efficient market hypothesis, they even allow passive index investing at a cost far below that of a mutual fund.
Tags: etf basics, etf investing, etfs, exchange-traded funds, Finance, index investing, Investing, investment, long term investing, money, passive investing, stock market, Wealth
This entry was posted on Thursday, April 2nd, 2009 at 7:54 pm and is filed under Investing. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. Both comments and pings are currently closed.